Chemistry:    Science  

-examples, chemical reactions 

-what are scientific questions

-scale of observations

-causal mechanisms, integrative models , physical objects

--------------------------------------------------

Philosophy àNatural philosophy Science
 Science is a set of processes/activities governed by the scientific method and based on the experimental observations of matter (physical objects) with a goal to acquire new knowledge. Scientist use models and theories to organize knowledge and provide better understanding and provide useful predictions.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Modern science : scientific method .

SCIENTIFIC METHOD (image)

 

Beginning: Most historians and science philosophers put the beginning of the scientific method around the first millennium After Christ (1100s) in the western civilization. Can you recognized people involved?  Key components: technology, universities/monasteries, need for "truth method"........

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

One of the visual presentations of  models related to the scientific method.

 

 

 

 

We can say when SM started , not when is completed. Very important!!!  The scientific method should be considered as iterative,  " work in progress".

Some of definitions used in the literature:

 
Hypothesis

 

A tentative interpretation or explanation of your observations or relations between observables

ü“the sweet taste of soda pop is due to the presence of sugar”

A good hypothesis is one that can be tested to be proved true or false (wrong)!

üFalsifiable :  "Falsifiability or refutability of a HYPOTHESIS or THEORY is the requirement that it can be  IN AGREEMENT OR DISAGREEMENT (contadiction) by an observation  (empirical) or the result of an  experiment (experimental). Note that "falsifiable"  is not the same as false

**********

One test may invalidate your hypothesis. It is important relation between the formulation and experiment.

In principle , all tha is not under that relation is not tested

 

 
 
EXPERIMENT  (empirical and experimental appraches)

Tests of hypotheses, laws or theories (predetermined goals)

Can you think of a way to test whether the sweet taste of soda pop is due to the presence of sugar?

 

THE METHOD:

Results either Validate (confirm-TRUE) or Invalidate (deny-FALSE) your ideas

üInvalidate = Discard or Modify

ØMany times experiments invalidate only parts of the hypothesis or theory, in which case the idea is modified

üValidate ≠ Proof your idea will always hold

 

Also often used: Laws answer the question What will happen.

The scientific method has limits here because of the scope of application.

 

Theories answer the question Why does something happen.

üTheory is expected to allow you to predict what will happen and possibly address the causality.

The scientific method has limits here because of the scope of application.

 
What is added in the last two decades?

Modern scientific methods: all parts of the method are important.

Need : Well defined hypothesis

 INSTRUMENTATION - EXPERIMENT - THEORY

MODELING-VISUALIZATION- IMAGING

COMPUTATION - MODELS

OBJECTIVITY

CONCEPT  origins and insights

 

EXAMPLES:

Questions?  Models? Hypothesis ?  Theories? Policies?

old paradigms and new paradigms

 

 

 

 

Columbus: quantitative aspects and instrumentation                          Picture from a 1550 edition of: "On the Sphere of the World". The most influential astronomy textbook of the 13th century.Science and quantitative and qualitative issues in discoveries.

                             

Try: More examples on successful and unsuccessful experiments.

What scientists did?

Issues: Truth, Ethics, Misconduct,  etc.  Arsenic DNA debate

Limits to discoveries? Are they real?

 

Picture taken from a Hetzel copy of Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea

What limits experiment, theory ??  Are there established  physical limits, uncertainties?

Limit speed, uncertainty.........

Real limits today?    Science -August 10, 2007

Figure 1

Figure 2

Figure 1

Figure 3Figure 4

 

Consequences: looking at old paradigms in a new light.....

 

Figure 1

Figure 2

x scale 0.1 attosec

y scale 0.01 attosec           

      Rupnik ( August 2007)

Are there then limits in unceratinties?

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------...

Our first PCHEM  experiment(s)?

 

Use SM. What are SM components associated with the experiment?